Glass is Not a Slow Flowing Liquid

By lordZB on Thursday, July 18, 2013
Texture tall old windows
“Don’t tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass.” —Anton Chekhov

In a Nutshell

It’s often said the glass in old windows is thicker at the bottom of a pane because over time the glass has flowed downwards. It’s true that glass is an amorphous solid, and so can be described (technically) as a fluid, but it moves so slowly at room temperature that changes would never be noticeable. Most metals are far more fluid than glass. Old glass appears thicker in some parts because it was blown and stretched rather than poured like modern glass.

The Whole Bushel

It is a common myth that glass, such as that found in old windows, is thicker at the bottom than at the top because it flows over time. It is even said that glass is a ‘super cooled liquid.’ The suggestion is that over time gravity has made the ‘liquid’ glass run.

Glass is not a liquid, but neither is it a solid. The molecular arrangement within glass is not as rigidly ordered as in a crystal nor as loosely associated as in a liquid. Glass is an amorphous solid. This means that it displays a certain amount of fluidity. So doesn’t that mean it really is runny?

Not to any real extent. The ability of a substance to flow is called viscosity. The higher the viscosity the less runny a substance is; honey is more viscous than water. Viscosity is measured in units called poises. Water at room temperature has a viscosity of 0.01 poises, olive oil 1 poise. The viscosity of glass? Approximately 100,000,000,000,000,000,000 poises. In other words you could leave a pane of glass for a million years and never notice it flowing.

Any difference in the thickness of old windows is due to imperfections in the manufacturing process. Flat glass is actually made by cutting blown cylinders of molten glass which is then pulled flat. Do this incorrectly and you will end up with an uneven pane.

Show Me The Proof

Physics FAQ: Is Glass Liquid or Solid
Corning Museum of Glass: Does Glass Flow?
Scientific American: Fact or Fiction?: Glass Is a (Supercooled) Liquid

  • mca

    I like this new page. Quick and informative. It’s a nice “dessert” to listverse.

    • http://listverse.com/ Jamie Frater

      That’s exactly what we were going for 🙂

  • rhijulbec

    If that’s what you are going for Jamie, you have successfully done just that. Excellent.

  • anonymouse72

    I love the fact I was told it was a misconception because of LV, but learnt a lot more on KN!

    yeah, JF is awesome

  • SugarMag26

    I was going to propose a totally chaotic, insane, upside-down, exciting marriage to Frater (a marriage to fit right in with my life) until I read you, lordZB. Whaddya say? You’d never be bored.

    Oh, I meant that I’m already addicted. I’ve just traded one drug for another. I must up my data allowance on my plan. A sincere thank you.

  • ElisaR89

    I’m addicted to this page! Love it!

  • Malcolm Garrison

    Nice new site:) can wait for the new entries ^_^

  • job alerts jobs
  • Telugu Cinema

    Nice Information :

    Telugu Cinema Contains Telugu Cinema
    News, Latest Movie Reviews, Actor, Actress, Movie Galleries And Many More @ http://www.telugucinema.com/