The Uzbek Scholar Who Discovered America Centuries Before Columbus

“A man of genius makes no mistakes. His errors are volitional and are the portals of discovery.” —Ulysses, James Joyce

In A Nutshell

Abu Raihan al-Biruni was born in what is now Uzbekistan and spent most of his life in Central Asia, miles from the sea. Arguably the greatest scholar of his era, his work on the Earth’s circumference led him to realize that there must be another large landmass to the West—and that it must be inhabited. He died in 1048, more than four centuries before Columbus set off, confidently expecting to sail to Asia.

The Whole Bushel

Abu Raihan al-Biruni is not a household name in the West. But he should be. The Central Asian scholar’s phenomenal intellect and breathtaking discoveries should rank him alongside Aristotle, Galileo, and Newton in the pantheon of pre-modern scientific geniuses. His life was difficult at best—he never knew his father, and the region he lived in was going through a particularly war-torn period, forcing Biruni to frequently uproot himself and flee from various conflicts. Despite this, he managed to produce an astonishing 146 works. Only 22 have survived, but they are more than enough to secure his reputation for brilliance.

Hundreds of years before Copernicus, he demonstrated that it was possible for the Earth to revolve around the Sun rather than the other way around, although he concluded that he could not definitely prove it either way and called on mathematicians to do more work on the subject. Observing that fossils were sometimes found on remote mountains, he suggested that they had once been underwater, anticipating plate tectonics. In a move sure to endear him to modern skeptics, he dismissed astrological horoscopes as “sorcery.” His work on specific gravity was groundbreaking.

But Biruni’s greatest achievements lay in his work on latitude and longitude. A youthful interest in geography led him to begin collecting or calculating precise coordinates of various towns and cities across the known world. While still in his twenties, he used this data to calculate the precise circumference of the Earth, which he used to produce a new globe unparalleled until the Renaissance. Later in life, he developed a new technique using spherical trigonometry and the law of sines which allowed him to make even more accurate calculations. His ultimate estimate of the Earth’s circumference was only 17 kilometers (10.44 mi) off from our modern figures.

These calculations led Biruni to an astonishing realization. Once he knew the size of the Earth, Biruni could not help but notice that the known world—Asia, Europe, and Africa—only occupied a small part of it—two-fifths at best. So what was in the other three-fifths? Biruni dismissed the accepted view that the world consisted of one central landmass surrounded by a vast ocean—if a landmass had arisen in the known two-fifths of the world, he deduced, there was no logical reason why a similar process wouldn’t have occurred in the remaining three-fifths. Since the Eurasian/African landmass straddled the equator, Biruni reasoned that the mysterious other continent would likely do the same, since it would have arisen from the same processes. That meant that the new land would have a roughly similar climate and would almost certainly be capable of supporting human life.

Biruni made most of these discoveries in a hilltop fortress in what is now Pakistan, where he had fled to avoid the attentions of a particularly cruel local warlord. In a castle north of modern Islamabad, hundreds of miles from the sea, an 11th-century genius realized that the people of the Old World were not alone on this planet. In a way, his achievement was more impressive, if less world-shaking, than that of Columbus, who fully believed he could sail to Asia.

Show Me The Proof

Photo credit: David Stanley
History Today: So, Who Did Discover America?
Encyclopaedia Britannica: al-Biruni
Classical Scientific Astrology, by George C. Noonan

  • Hillyard

    The genius of our forefathers (and mothers) never ceases to amaze me.

  • Joseph

    The title doesn’t even match the article at all. I just “discovered” a habitable planet that isn’t Earth because space is big! Whoever makes the titles for listverse and knowledgenuts is terrible at it… Anyway, it was a very good article and I enjoyed reading it.

    • Joseph Wilson

      What would you suggest?

      • Joseph

        The Uzbek scholar that correctly hypothesized the existence of America. I enjoyed reading the article. I just don’t think that “discovery” is the best word to use.

        • Joseph Wilson

          I have to say, I suck at titles. I wouldn’t even know where to begin to entice readers.

        • Tim Johnson

          Or better yet: The Uzbek scholar who predicted a habitable land mass on the other side of the world.

  • inconspicuous detective

    who didn’t discover america before columbus?

    • Nomsheep

      I did.

    • I never LOL

      • inconspicuous detective

        mm?

  • Nathaniel A.

    In general, Central Asian scholars (Arab and others from the steppe) are overlooked in favor of Europeans and Far East Asians.

  • WM

    He was Persian not an Uzbek!

    • He was too according to Google