Your Height Could Influence How You’ll Die

“The tall, the wise, the reverend head, / Must lie as low as ours.” —Isaac Watts

In A Nutshell

A series of studies that have looked at the correlation between height and death have come across some startling statistics. While shorter people are statistically more likely to die from heart disease or stroke (possibly because of the size of the arteries), taller people have a higher chance of being diagnosed with cancer. Taller women are at a higher risk of developing blood clots than shorter ones, but many other factors—including things like lifestyle and genetics—make the whole matter incredibly complicated.

The Whole Bushel

We’re all aware of the impact our weight has on our health and longevity, but what about height?

A handful of studies have been done on the links between height and causes of death or chronic illnesses. It turns out that whether you’re tall or short, there’s some bad news for you.

A study headed by professors from the UK’s University of Leicester looked at a possible connection between height and heart disease. They investigated 180 genetic markers and specifically looked for those associated with both height and heart disease.

They found evidence that the shorter you are, the more likely you are to develop coronary heart disease.

For every 6.35-centimeter (2.5 in) increase in a person’s height, that person’s chances of developing coronary artery disease dropped by an average of 13.5 percent. When they isolated the genetic markers that were associated with increased height, they found that the people who had the most instances of these markers were 26 percent less likely to develop the condition than those at the bottom of the range.

While they note that lifestyle choices have a huge impact on likelihood of developing heart disease, they say that the correlation is too great to dismiss outright.

Importantly, the link was only found in men. Another study, published in the European Heart Journal, supports the link and suggests that it has something to do with the smaller coronary arteries that develop in shorter people.

It’s not all that clear-cut, though. Another study from the American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association seemed to find a different pattern when their research connected height to strokes. More than 10,000 men were involved in the 23-year study.

This study found that the taller a person was, the less chance they had of dying of a stroke, even when factoring in lifestyle and age.

Before tall people start celebrating, there’s some bad news for them, too. According to research by the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, for every 10 centimeters (4 in) of height you add, you’re also adding a 13 percent increase in the likelihood of a cancer diagnosis. And that includes nearly all types of cancer, from thyroid and kidney cancer to breast cancer.

Taller women are also at a greater risk for developing blood clots. According to the researchers for an Iowa women’s health project, they found that women who suffered more than one blood clot were taller, and those taller than 168 centimeters (5’6”) were 76 percent more likely to have recurring blood clots than those who were only 158 centimeters (5’2”) tall.

The whole idea of height as an indicator of other health risks had something of an unlikely origin.

The popularity of height and weight tables really took off thanks to the insurance industry, when people who were underweight were considered the biggest risks. The theory was that if someone who didn’t have some extra weight on them were to contract tuberculosis (or a similar disease), they would have less reserves to draw on and were more likely to die quickly.

It was only when modern medicine caught up and started making many of these diseases controllable—if not altogether obsolete—that there was a shift in what was considered an ideal combination of height and weight.

Show Me The Proof

LiveScience: Why Short People May Have Higher Risk of Heart Disease
“Body Height Is Associated With Decreased Long-Term Stroke but Not Coronary Heart Disease Mortality?” by Uri Goldbourt and David Tanne
European Heart Journal: Short stature is associated with coronary heart disease
Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention: Adult Stature and Risk of Cancer at Different Anatomic Sites in a Cohort of Postmenopausal Women
Iowa Women’s Health Study: Adult Stature and Risk of Cancer at Different Anatomic Sites in a Cohort of Postmenopausal Women
US National Library of Medicine: Average? Ideal? Desirable?

  • samarastt

    Actually shorter, smaller people have inherently lower risk of coronary heart disease (CHD). For example, 20th Century studies found that people in the Solomon Islands, Papua New Guinea, Kalahari bushmen, and Congo pygmies were both short and free of CHD and stroke. Many other examples show shorter people have less heart disease than taller people. Comparisons between taller northern Europe and shorter southern Europe show the north to have 40% higher incidence of heart disease. In the 1960’s, the Cretan people were shorter than central and northern Europeans but they had the lowest CHD in Europe. Today they are taller and heavier than in the 1960s and are experiencing an alarming increase in heart disease.

    While epidemiological studies do find taller people in the developed world have lower CHD, they are probably confounded by the fact that lower socioeconomic (SES) status is associated with higher CHD independent of other risk factors. Studies also show people in lower SES are shorter and more overweight than people in higher SES. Therefore, it is not shorter height per se that is the cause of heart disease. For example, when short and tall people in the lower class are compared, taller people have a 40% higher risk of angina or a heart attack.

    The belief that shorter people inherently have higher CHD makes no sense when you look at the historic facts. For example, before the industrial revolution, CHD and other modern chronic diseases were rare. Yet, people were shorter then. Even in 1900, CHD was rare compared to today and people were shorter. And don’t forget that women are shorter than men have less heart disease. No tall populations can compete with the short CHD-free populations mentioned before.

    Recently researcher Nunney reported that, based on recent and past studies, there was little doubt that taller height was related to increases in most cancers.

    Another article that was published a month age found 36 biological parameters or factors that explain why shorter, smaller people have less cardiovascular disease and greater longevity. These parameters are consistent with about 100 studies showing that shorter people have lower mortality rates, higher survival rates and greater longevity. See: Samaras TT. Biological parameters explain why shorter, smaller people have lower cardiovascular disease and greater longevity. 15(1): 1-16, 2017; Article no.JSRR.34729 DOI: 10.9734/JSRR/2017/34729

    Most studies show centenarians to be short and light. For example, Chan, Suzuki and Yamamoto reported that being short and light is an advantage in reaching 100 years of age. Many researchers since the 1960s have reported that smaller individuals within a species live longer. On an individual basis, tall people can live to be 100+ but this depends on genetics, nutrition, exercise, non-smoking, and a healthy lifestyle with good medical care.

    ISSN: 2320-0227

  • Xan Xan
  • samarastt

    The higher death rate of shorter people from coronary heart disease (CHD) is not due to biological considerations. We know that many short populations in Europe and the south Pacific have much lower CHD than taller North Americans and northern Europeans. For example, people in the Solomon islands were found to have no CHD or strokes based on 20C studies. They were about 5’4″. Thus, if being short was a biological problem, these islanders would not have been so heart healthy. In addition, in1900, CHD was rare compared to today. Yet, people were 3 to 4 inches shorter than they are today. Before 1970, taller upper class US people had more deaths from heart disease than shorter working class people. After 1970, the pattern reversed and workers had the highest levels but relative height differences didn’t change. This was probably due to changes in eating patterns and consumption of cheap, fast food by lower income people compared to higher income people.There are many other examples that show shorter people having lower CHD compared to the well-off people in developed and non-developed countries. Research has also shown that small dogs also have much lower rayes of heart failure than bigger dogs.